The Traveling Taylors

We stayed just steps from the divide between Edinburgh New Town and Old Town, and honestly? They felt like two totally different cities. Both are stunning, both are walkable—but they each offer a very different vibe. So if you’re trying to decide where to stay, explore, or eat first, this honest breakdown of Edinburgh New Town vs. Old Town will help you make the most of your time in Scotland’s capital.

The Vibe: Medieval Maze vs. Georgian Grandeur

Old Town:

• Winding cobbled streets, alleyways (called “closes”), and layered architecture
• Feels ancient, mysterious, and storybook-like
• More tourists, street performers, and bustling energy

New Town:

• Wide streets, symmetrical layouts, and elegant Georgian buildings
• Feels refined, calm, and a bit posh
• More local businesses, boutique shops, and less foot traffic

Quick Take: Old Town is moody and historic. New Town is graceful and spacious.

Architecture: Gothic Drama vs. Classical Chic

Old Town:

• Medieval, gothic, and unpredictable
• Iconic spots: Edinburgh Castle, St. Giles Cathedral, Royal Mile

New Town:

• Planned Georgian architecture, stone terraces, and garden squares
• Iconic spots: Princes Street, Charlotte Square, and the Scott Monument

Fun Fact: New Town isn’t really “new”— it was built in the late 1700s to escape Old Town’s overcrowding.

Food Scene: Hearty Classics vs. Trendy Bites

Old Town:

• Pub food, haggis, and traditional Scottish fare
• Many places cater to tourists, but some gems are hidden in the closes

New Town:

• Sleek cafes, cocktail bars, modern Scottish dining
• More vegetarian and international options
• Try: The Ivy, Hawksmoor, or Dishoom

Pro Tip: Bypass Princes Street chains and head to George Street or Thistle Street for better food.

Views & Photography: Rooftops vs. Skyline

Old Town:

• Best for skyline shots from Calton Hill or Victoria Street
• Romantic, layered architecture that feels cinematic

New Town:

• Best for street symmetry, elegant facades, and rooftop bars
• Calton Hill technically sits on the New Town side, offering epic views of both

Quick Tip: Golden hour on North Bridge captures both towns beautifully.

Shopping: Tartan or Tailored?

Old Town:

• Souvenir shops, wool, whisky, and kitschy gifts
• Ideal for grabbing Scotland-themed presents

New Town:

• Designer boutiques, local fashion, bookstores, and galleries
• Explore Multrees Walk, Frederick Street, and Broughton Street

Where to Stay: Depends on Your Travel Style

• ✨ Stay in Old Town if: You want to be steps from major attractions and love that medieval vibe
• 🛏️ Stay in New Town if: You prefer quieter nights, classy surroundings, and better hotel deals

Good to Know: You can walk between the two in under 15 minutes, so you’re never far from either side.

Edinburgh New Town vs. Old Town

So—Edinburgh New Town vs. Old Town? It’s not about which is better—it’s about what you want to experience. Old Town offers drama, depth, and atmosphere. New Town brings balance, style, and ease. The best trip includes both—but now you’ll know where to wander first, and why.